Stove Repair vs Replacement: Which Is Right for You?

If your stove is acting up, the first question is whether to repair it or replace it. It’s a common dilemma for homeowners, and the answer depends on a few practical factors. You don’t need a checklist of 20 items—just consider age, cost, safety, and how you use your stove. Below we break down the key points so you can decide quickly and avoid wasting money.

When to Repair Your Stove

Repair is usually the best choice if the stove is relatively new—under eight years old—and the problem is isolated. A broken igniter, a faulty thermostat, or a cracked burner can often be fixed for a fraction of the price of a new unit. If the repair estimate is less than 40‑50% of the cost of a comparable new stove, it’s generally worth fixing.

Safety is another big reason to repair. Leaking gas or a malfunctioning heating element can be dangerous. Getting a qualified Glastonbury technician to replace the part restores safety without the hassle of a full removal.

Energy efficiency matters too. Modern stoves use less power, but an older model that’s still in good shape can be upgraded with a more efficient part. That small upgrade can lower your bills while keeping the familiar look and feel of your kitchen.

When to Replace Your Stove

If your stove is over ten years old and you’re seeing multiple issues—like uneven heating, frequent breakdowns, or rust—you’re probably looking at a replacement. At this point, repair costs add up, and older appliances may lack modern safety features.

Consider the cost of future repairs. When each fix costs a few hundred pounds, a new stove becomes more economical in the long run. New models also come with warranties, so you get peace of mind for several years.

Efficiency upgrades are another driver. New stoves meet stricter energy standards, meaning lower electricity or gas use. If you’re renovating the kitchen, a new stove can match the fresh design and add resale value to your home.

Finally, think about convenience. Some repairs require the stove to be off for days, while a new stove can be installed and working within a single visit by our Glastonbury team.

Bottom line: if the repair cost is low, the stove is relatively young, and safety isn’t a concern, go with repair. If the unit is old, the repair bill is high, or you want better efficiency, replace it. Our local technicians can give you a free quote, explain the options, and help you make the best decision for your budget and kitchen.

Whatever you choose, act quickly. Ignoring a minor fault can turn into a major breakdown, costing more time and money. Call Glastonbury Appliance Repair Services today and get a clear, honest assessment—no pressure, just practical advice.